Boating Accidents on Percy Priest Reservoir and Old Hickory Lake

HomeBlogBoating Accidents on Percy Priest Reservoir and Old Hickory Lake
Boating Accidents on Percy Priest Reservoir and Old Hickory Lake
  |   Aug 19, 2026  |  Blog

Boating Accidents on Percy Priest Reservoir and Old Hickory Lake

Quick answer: Percy Priest Reservoir and Old Hickory Lake rank among Tennessee’s most dangerous waterways, consistently leading the state in serious injuries, capsizings, and fatal boating incidents. Common causes include high-speed collisions, missing life jackets, alcohol impairment, and reckless operation.

Every summer, families head to Percy Priest Reservoir and Old Hickory Lake for a day on the water. These lakes are two of Tennessee’s most popular recreational destinations, drawing thousands of boaters, jet skiers, and swimmers each season. But beneath the fun is a serious danger that claims lives every year.

Both lakes consistently rank among the most deadly waterways in the state. Understanding why these Percy Priest boating accidents and Old Hickory boating accidents keep happening, and how to prevent them, could save your life or the life of someone you love.

Why Are Percy Priest and Old Hickory Lakes So Dangerous?

Heavy recreational traffic is one of the biggest problems on both lakes. High-speed boats and personal watercraft share the same water with swimmers and slower vessels, creating an unpredictable and often chaotic environment. Variable water depths, submerged obstacles left behind by the original dammed riverbeds, and sudden weather changes add to the risk.

Many operators simply underestimate these lakes. Because they are familiar, local destinations, boaters may let their guard down, operating at unsafe speeds or skipping basic safety precautions they would otherwise follow.

What Causes Most Boating Accidents on These Lakes?

1. High-Speed Collisions

Speed is a recurring factor in some of the most tragic Old Hickory boating accidents on record. In summer 2024, 10-year-old Jack Gear was killed when the jet ski he was riding at the Boxwell Reservation on Old Hickory Lake was struck by another jet ski traveling at a high rate of speed. A camp staffer was critically injured in the same collision. 

Two individuals, Joshua Kennington and Savannah Remington, were charged with vehicular homicide by reckless endangerment and multiple violations of boating safety regulations, including failing to operate at a safe speed and stop at an appropriate distance.

This tragedy is not an isolated case. It is a stark example of what can happen when watercraft are operated recklessly on busy lakes.

2. Missing Life Jackets

According to data cited by the Tennessee Wildlife Resources Agency (TWRA), the majority of boating fatalities involve individuals who were not wearing life jackets when they entered the water or fell overboard. A life jacket can mean the difference between a rescue and a recovery.

3. Alcohol Impairment

The TWRA identifies alcohol as a primary contributing factor in seasonal boating incidents on Tennessee lakes. Operating a watercraft while impaired is both illegal and deadly.

4. Distracted and Reckless Operation

Failing to maintain safe speeds, ignoring other vessels, and general inattention are consistent factors in Percy Priest boating accidents and collisions across both lakes.

How to Stay Safe on Percy Priest and Old Hickory Lakes

Preventing boating accidents starts with personal responsibility. Before heading out on the water, follow these steps:

  • Wear a properly fitted life jacket at all times, especially on open water
  • Operate at safe speeds and keep appropriate distances from other vessels and swimmers
  • Never drink and boat, even if you feel alert and in control
  • Check weather conditions before departure and monitor them throughout the day
  • Complete a boating safety course and familiarize yourself with TWRA regulations

These steps are straightforward, but they are frequently overlooked, often with devastating consequences.

Were You Injured in a Boating Accident on Percy Priest or Old Hickory Lake?

If you or a loved one was injured, or if you lost a family member in a boating accident on Percy Priest Reservoir or Old Hickory Lake, you may be entitled to compensation. Negligent operators, unsafe watercraft, and inadequate supervision can all give rise to legal claims.

Bill Easterly & Associates is here to help. Our team can review your case, explain your legal options, and guide you through the process of seeking justice. Contact us today to schedule a consultation.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the most common causes of boating accidents on Percy Priest and Old Hickory Lakes?

The most common causes include high-speed collisions, failure to wear life jackets, alcohol impairment, and reckless or distracted operation. The Tennessee Wildlife Resources Agency cites these factors consistently in seasonal boating investigations on both lakes.

Are Percy Priest and Old Hickory Lakes more dangerous than other Tennessee waterways?

Yes. Both lakes consistently rank among the most dangerous waterways in Tennessee, frequently leading the state in serious injuries, capsizings, and fatal incidents, largely due to heavy recreational traffic and high-speed watercraft.

What should I do if I was injured in a boating accident on these lakes?

Seek medical attention immediately, document the scene and any injuries, report the accident to the TWRA, and contact a boating accident attorney to understand your legal rights and options for compensation.

Can I file a lawsuit after a boating accident on Percy Priest or Old Hickory Lake?

Yes. If your injury or a loved one’s death resulted from another operator’s negligence, reckless operation, or failure to follow boating regulations, you may have grounds for a legal claim. Contact Bill Easterly & Associates to discuss the specifics of your case.

Is it required to wear a life jacket on Percy Priest and Old Hickory Lakes?

Tennessee law requires children under 13 to wear a life jacket at all times while on a moving vessel. For adults, life jackets must be on board and accessible, though wearing one at all times is strongly recommended.

Bill Easterly
Bill Easterly
Bill Easterly is a Nashville attorney and founder of Bill Easterly & Associates, with a strong commitment to community service and youth sports through the West Nashville Sports League.

Categories

Featured Shorts

Contact Us Today

Fields Marked With an "*" Are Required